|>> || |
I think people are oversensitive in regard to the Ferengi and the... black planet, for lack of a better term. For starters, the Ferengi don't share any ACTUAL characteristics with Jews. They merely share some of the same stereotypes. And let's be real, here. The sort of stereotypes the Jews got saddled with, and which show up in the Ferengi, are your basic unflattering stereotypes. Exagerated facial features, hunched gait, and a penchant for base scheming are just as much stereotypes of Fantasy monsters like Goblins. The Ferengi exhibit these traits because they're meant to be unlikable, not because they're supposed to be Jews.
So what's the other link? They like money. They're consumate traders. Oh, and they're raging misogynists, which is not a stereotype of Jews at all. Riker basically comes out and says it when they're first mentioned: Ferengi are an extremely heavyhanded "criticism" on capitalism. The original Ferengi could be straight out of Soviet propaganda if you just fatten them up a little and put them in a three-piece suit with top hat. Probably the entire idea behind them was to show how what we consider normal would look literally monstrous and pathetic to the people in Star Trek.
But they're not fucking Jews, they were never intended to be Jews, there's no accidental, subconscious similarity between them and Jews. The only link is that they're often played by Jewish actors for some reason. But why would a Jew play a Jewish stereotype? Because the money is good?
Part of me thinks people just enjoy pointing this shit out. A legit form of "virtue signalling", if you will. A connect the dots between the features of the Ferengi and those of Jews in Nazi propaganda, without getting into any detail, and here's a tiny issue one can be mock-offended over.
I'm from a people with a tradition of trade. Not everyone has liked us because of it. Those "Jewish" stereotypes that are applied to the Ferengi? Also applied to us, right down to being know for having big noses. Because these are stereotypes people readily apply to some "other", especially if they don't like them.
As for the black planet, the accusations of racism are again vague. They're a planet of retards like we've seen a dozen times in TOS and TNG, except this time everyone is black. That's not *that* much of a radical departure from TNG's regular antics. Again, they exhibit no actual stereotypes that people associate with black people. Not that I could tell, anyway. Sure, they're backwards tribals, but not in the way people usually attribute to black people. Despite what you say, they're not actually "spearchuckers". They seem much closer to a species like Klingons, in terms of culture.
Compare them to Up The Long Ladder, and you see the difference between maybe an unfortune casting choice and actual, deliberate, conscious racism. The aloofness and superiority of the crew, the constant rapid-fire stereotypes, none of it being funny, and all of it done in front of a cast member who is from that culture. The black planet is nothing compared to that. Instead, you see the crew treat that aliens as equal, respecting their customs even when a crewmember is at risk, and at the end there's the twist that actually the women have a lot more control than you'd think, despite being treated as property. Is it a good episode? No. But it's fairly typical of TOS and early TNG, and hits the same notes as all the episodes where not everyone on the planet is black.
So that's really the only thing. They're all black. A useless, superfluous casting decision made for a reason I'm not aware of. The decision itself is more racist than the episode, though. Maybe they intended some point that was ultimately lost, and probably impossible to make within the framework of Star Trek. It's not like the TNG crew is going to notice they're all black. Some scene with "I couldn't help but notice your entire planet is monoracial" would have gone over even worse.
But the racism is firmly in the eye of the beholder, I think. These dudes are pretty much identical to all the other shitty cultures the Enterprise slaps its dick in the face off. In fact, now I'm thinking of the white-robed people that almost killed Wesley, and the SFDebris guy basically called THAT episode racist because all of THEM were white. So what the fuck is it people want, anyway? Make them all black, and you're being racist against black people? Make them all white, and you're being racist against black people? Of course, the argument is "the black guys are all savages, and the white guys are civilized" but that's pure fucking nonsense, and people just seeing what they want to see. The white-robed fitness planet was a world of indolent idiots with possibly the worst system of law seen in Trek, ever. Which includes shit like trial by combat and a fascist system where your sentence is known before the trial even starts, so that's saying something. And they're all being puppet-mastered by some invisible space-god who doesn't want them to join the Galactic community. By comparison, at least Planet jolly african-american seems like an actual, functional culture that gets shit done.